[JimDabell]

I agree. I know from looking at a story that if Alice picks it up it’ll take her about a day and be decent quality, but if Bob picks it up it’ll take him about a week and be worse quality. And I know that this will be pretty consistent week-in, week-out.

Developer productivity exists and I am totally comfortable describing Alice as being more productive than Bob. The fact that there isn’t a good, generic way to distill this into particular values does not mean that the phenomenon doesn’t exist.

We’ve all worked with Alice and Bobs. Claiming there’s no such thing as developer productivity is denying what we’ve all experienced. We aren’t special snowflakes whose work is beyond the ken of mortal men. Our work has value and sometimes we produce a lot of value in a particular time period and sometimes we product a little. This is productivity.