Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dagss 550 days ago
Not sure if it helps, but trying: In a sense area isn't anything else than multiplication. It isn't like you have a) multiplication and b) area and then prove that a=b.

Rather, area IS multiplication.

The unit of "square meter" quite literally means "meter multiplied by meter".

2 comments

I agree and I'd say that area is almost, in some intuitive way, the more basic thing and multiplication follows from that (although I know that's not mathematically true). The definition of multiplication for natural numbers is repeated addition (e.g. 3 x 5 is defined to be 5 + 5 + 5). Many people would see that as the count of a 3 by 5 grid of objects, and that's certainly how we'd explain the commutativity of multiplication in school. If those individual objects happen to be unit squares then you have area.
In fact, it wouldn’t surprise me if multiplication was first invented to calculate areas (e.g. of agricultural fields).
I would say area is integration, and that, for the simple case of integrating a constant function, equals multiplication of that constant by the length of the interval being integrated over (measure of the set, if you’re doing Lebesgue integration)