Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wrsh07 558 days ago
Here's the money stuff excerpt: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/02/th...

> I feel like most of what I read about payment for order flow is insane? Otherwise normal people will start out mainstream explainer articles by saying, like, “Robinhood sells your order to Citadel so Citadel can front-run it.” No! First of all, it is illegal to front-run your order, and the Securities and Exchange Commission does, you know, keep an eye on this stuff. Second, the wholesaler is ordinarily filling your order at a price that is better than what’s available in the public market, so “front-running”—going out and buying on the stock exchange and then turning around and selling to you at a profit—doesn’t work. Third, because retail orders are generally uninformative, the wholesaler is not rubbing its hands together being like “bwahahaha now I know that Matt Levine is buying GameStop, it will definitely go up, I must buy a ton of it before he gets any!” The whole story is widely accepted but also completely transparent nonsense.

1 comments

it's already public that frontrunning is perfectly legal if you can do it with large volume as to not show intent of frontrunning one single person.
yeah, Citadel's annual $30,000,000,000 profit is not coming out of thin air or just from bid-ask spread. Customers are being taken for a ride definitely