[chx]

That would be some really old library. Already in 2012 when Composer was released there was PSR-0 and today almost all libraries are Composer managed and using a namespace following PSR-4 which itself is ten years old. A library that old would almost surely not run on PHP 8 unchanged anyways.

Surrendering the global namespace to the language is not so bad an idea.

[nneonneo]

Suppose I want to add some new code to an old website? Or I want to gradually upgrade an ancient code base - twelve years is not so old for PHP, when ancient frameworks like Wordpress are still alive and kicking.

[chx]

If we hitched language development on Wordpress we would still be on PHP4 as they refused to join gophp5 some seventeen years ago.

Again, an ancient enough codebase which contains a library using array_find will need enough upgrades to run on PHP8 much less PHP8.4 the change from array_find to something else is the least of your worries.

[nneonneo]

Seriously? 2k results for array_find in PHP on GitHub: https://github.com/search?q=array_find++language%3APHP&type=.... RFC authors (https://wiki.php.net/rfc/array_find) explicitly noted over 600 hits for definitions of array_find, around 30% of which are not false positives - that is, there's a good possibility that there are 200+ implementations of global array_find in just open-source projects.

First page hits https://github.com/hawind/gdoo/blob/master/app/Support/helpe..., a PHP app last updated just two years ago (140 stars, 63 forks) which only supports PHP 8.x. Implementation is thoroughly incompatible with 8.4's array_find.

There are so many more examples. Lots of the hits are from codebases that have seen updates in the last few years. Many more are plugins or other addons for PHP frameworks or apps which are still widely used (WordPress, phpBB, etc.).

[alganet]

The example you picked:

https://github.com/hawind/gdoo/blob/master/app/Support/helpe...

Is namespaced. You need to realize that \array_find is different from \Illuminate\Support\Arr\array_find.

There is zero chance of collision here. Totally compatible.

[nneonneo]

IIUC the `use` declaration is including the target namespace (https://laravel.com/api/8.x/Illuminate/Support/Arr.html) in the current scope, not declaring a namespace itself. If you wanted to create a namespace you need the `namespace` declaration, which this file lacks. `helpers.php` is directly included by both `index.php` and `artisan` and the functions are thereby in the global scope of the entire app.

In any case, it wouldn't make sense for that file to be namespaced under Illuminate\Support\Arr, as most of those functions have nothing to do with arrays.

[alganet]

Fair enough, you're right!

Anyway, it _could_ have been namespaced. It _should_ have been namespaced. I'm sad for the app author, but he should have seen that coming. His app was developed well after namespaces were introduced.

You're making impossible demands. PHP has chosen to be backwards compatible _to a certain point in the past_, and it is generous in what it decides to keep working.

To expect that 8.4 will care about not breaking some code that was written with 5.2 style is unrealistic.

You're making a time travel judgement. You're saying that PHP should have renamed everything back then to categorized namespaces and broken compatibility _way_ earlier, which is actually a much worse break than the break that actually happened.

[9dev]

Then you use your IDEs refactoring feature to rename your version of the function, or put it into a namespace, and you’re done in about 12 seconds.