Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WJW 580 days ago
Sure, but the amount of photons as a percentage of the background radiation drops as a function of the distance. It's not all that far away in cosmic distances when any signal from Earth is millions of times less powerful than the noise level.
1 comments
quantadev 580 days ago
> amount of photons as a percentage of the background

That's what "density" means. (i.e. the amount of something per unit volume)

> noise level

A photon will travel thru space forever without losing energy, unless it hits something. What noise are you talking about?

link
WJW 579 days ago
> A photon will travel thru space forever without losing energy, unless it hits something. What noise are you talking about?

I'm talking about the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noise_floor, in particular the unavoidable receiver noise caused by the cosmic background radiation.

A single photon is not a viable communication signal, certainly not at interstellar distances. In practice you need to send out some sort of modulated beam. Even very narrow beams have nonzero dispersion, so the further you get the lower the signal energy will be at an antenna of a given size. So to get more energy you'd need a bigger antenna, but that in turn means receiving more of the background noise as well. In practice there is a minimal signal strength level at which it is still practical to receive the signal.

Long story short: A photon will go on forever (unless it hits something), but a radio signal rapidly spreads out so much that no realistic receiver will be able to recover it from out of the cosmic background noise.

link
quantadev 579 days ago
I didn't say sending single photons at a time is a viable communications mechanism. I said a photon will travel indefinitely, without losing any energy, until it interacts with something.

Interestingly, if you send out a single photon from a radio antenna not even the universe itself will have 'determined' which direction it even went until it DOES interact, because there would be a Quantum Mechanical superposition/indeterminacy similar to the famous slit-experiment, if you were dealing with one photon at a time.

So even the thought experiment itself is complex due to wave/particle duality.

link