Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by znpy 587 days ago
It's not much data.

With current 22TB magnetic disks it's less than 20 disks, they would fit into a single machine (4u, likely).

The Storinator XL60 from 45drives (https://www.45drives.com/products/storinator-xl60-configurat...) can hold 60 disks, for (advertised) ~1.4PB of data.

(btw i've learned about 45drives through Linus Tech Tips channel so I think it's obligatory to say LTTSTORE.COM - for the meme)
2 comments
manacit 586 days ago
Just to address the core of your comment, 20 magnetic disks would combine for about ~2,000 IOPS of capacity, provide for no redundancy, and allow only one machine to process the entirety of the queries coming in to power the application.

Even a full 60 disk server filled with magnetic disks would provide less I/O capacity for running a relational database than a single EBS volume.

It's might not look like a lot of data if you're talking about storing media files, but it's quite a bit of relational data to be queried in single-digit milliseconds at-scale.

link
znpy 586 days ago
I assumed people did not need to be explicitly reminded that you had to provision additional capacity for redundancy, and that you can use different layers of caching (ssd caches, ram caches etc).

And by the way, it was just posted today that you can get 60TB pci gen5 SSDs from Micron: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42122434 : you can still fit all that dataset in a single machine and provide all the iops you need. You'd need just 7 of those.

So yeah, 400TB of data is not much data nowadays.

link
telgareith 587 days ago
45drives is... bad. I cannot understand why people would use them- particularly for homelab. Three SC846 24x3.5" 4U can be had for no more than $400/ea and, theres 36bay versions.

60 drives in 6U is a crap ton of weight.

link
znpy 586 days ago
> Three SC846 24x3.5" 4U can be had for no more than $400/ea and, theres 36bay versions.

Because then you need three times the rack space. What you don't spend one-time for the hardware you'll spend extra every month for rack space, connectivity, cooling, power etc.

You might use that budget for redundancy, for example.

link