[shkkmo]

> This is just a statement by someone that is desperately looking for a negative point

No it isn't.

This is an expert explaining why journals have ethical concerns publishing the paper and why those concerns matter.

>> “I think it ultimately does fall within the line of being ethical, but it isn’t a slam-dunk case,” says Sherkow, adding that he would have liked to see a commentary fleshing out the ethics perspective, published alongside the case report.