Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vetinari 596 days ago
Climate change is a part of Earth's lifecycle. There have been ice ages, and there have been periods like jura, when it was warmer. It's all natural.

What you probably mean is how humans influence this cycle; whether accelerating or delaying it, in effect disrupting it. For that, there's no evidence; however, there are many politician lobbyists (and yes, also scientists taking advantage of juicy grants to deliver what was ordered) going to capitalize on the fear that it might be.

2 comments

> how humans influence this cycle; whether accelerating or delaying it, in effect disrupting it. For that, there's no evidence;

Le sigh.

Here is a graph to explain the difference between what's happening now and previous changes:

https://xkcd.com/1732/

Do you get it?

As someone who believes in Anthropomorphic Climate change, that graphic is just horrendous. Here is another XKCD to explain why: https://xkcd.com/605/

To be less punchy: Most of the data on the graph is on a scale of 500 years and the data is filled in with dashed lines. Starting the late 1800's we suddenly have real data(what is the update frequency?, how does that compare to previous data?)

Here is the note on the graphic: "Limits of this data: Short warming or cooling spikes may be 'smoothed out' by these reconstructions but only if they are small enough or brief enough"

What is small enough? What is brief enough?