Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eigenspace 598 days ago
Fair enough. You may be totally right here, as I mentioned I don't use Python much at all since like 2017 and haven't paid it much attention in a while. I retract my comment.

Regarding breakage in 3.x, all I know is that I recall several times where I did a linux system update (rolling release), and that updated my Python to a newly released version which broke various things in my system. I'm pretty sure one of these was v3.10, but I forget which others caused me problems which I could only solve by pinning Python to an older release.

It's entirely possible though that no actual APIs were broken and that this was just accidentaly bugs in the release, or the packages were being naughty and relying on internals they shouldn't have relied on or something else.
1 comments
dagmx 598 days ago
To your last point: it’s neither the language nor the packages but rather it’s the ABI.

Python isn’t fully ABI stable (though it’s improved greatly) so you can’t just intermix compiled dependencies between different versions of Python.

This is true for many packages in your distro as well.

link
dbsmith83 598 days ago
There have been many breaking changes throughout python 3.x releases:

- standard library modules removed

- zip error handling behaves differently

- changes to collections module

- new reserved keywords (async, await, etc.)

You can argue how big of a deal it is or isn't, but there were definitely breakages that violate semantic versioning

link
maleldil 597 days ago
Python doesn't follow SemVer, that's why.

https://peps.python.org/pep-2026/

link
dbsmith83 597 days ago
Clearly, which is what I was showing. A poor design decision imo
link
eigenspace 598 days ago
They removed entire standard library modules? Wut.
link
heisenzombie 597 days ago
Yes, e.g. https://peps.python.org/pep-0594/
link
eigenspace 598 days ago
Ah I see. Yeah, I guess I just think that for a language that's so dependent on FFI, instability in the ABI is defacto instability in the language as far as I'm concerned. But I understand that not everyone feels the same.

Almost every major noteworthy Python package uses the ABI, so instability there is going to constantly be felt ecosystem wide.

link