Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cryptoz 5100 days ago
Let's say I have 20-30 windows open on a laptop connected to an external monitor (I do, right now). Windows 7 has one taskbar, and so it becomes extremely difficult/near impossible to quickly determine which window is on which screen. This could be improved by adding a second taskbar (I think this is coming in Windows 8?) but I think more is needed.

Additionally: some application titlebars can be dragged so the window appears on a different screen, but some cannot. Excel, when maximized, cannot be dragged to another screen.

Back to taskbar issues: My biggest complain pre-Windows 7 was that you could not reorder items. I thought they fixed it, but they actually made it a lot more annoying with W7. I think Windows assumes that each window of an application is related to the other windows (never the case with my workflow) and so you cannot separate them by dragging. Say I have 5 Firefox windows with a few tabs each, where each window's tabs represent a collection of related topics. Now say I have some Word and Excel documents also open that relate to the browser windows. I'd like to arrange Topic 1 from Firefox, Word and Excel on one monitor with their taskbar items together, Topic 2 on the second monitor with their items together, etc. It's very unpleasant and difficult to manage windows on Windows.

2 comments

Here's the thing...just because you aren't getting something exactly the way you want it...does not mean that the UX is somehow awful for every person using it.

Furthermore, Windows has left the hooks available for people so that they can change something if they don't like it. That's the best UX present any company can give you.

There are plenty of apps out there to modify Windows. As a matter of fact, there's very little that can't be modified. Why don't you just look around for some program to do what you want?

> does not mean that the UX is somehow awful for every person using it.

Oh I know - I was merely giving my own opinion.

> Why don't you just look around for some program to do what you want?

I'm not allowed to. This is a business computer, not a personal machine. Not everyone has the freedom to install third-party software to fix up bad UX in the OS they are using.

>This could be improved by adding a second taskbar (I think this is coming in Windows 8?) but I think more is needed.

Yes, this is coming in Windows 8. http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/05/21/enhancing-wind...

>My biggest complain pre-Windows 7 was that you could not reorder items. I thought they fixed it, but they actually made it a lot more annoying with W7. I think Windows assumes that each window of an application is related to the other windows (never the case with my workflow) and so you cannot separate them by dragging. Say I have 5 Firefox windows with a few tabs each, where each window's tabs represent a collection of related topics. Now say I have some Word and Excel documents also open that relate to the browser windows.

You can ungroup windows in the taskbar with 7 Taskbar Tweaker http://rammichael.com/?proj=29

> You can ungroup windows in the taskbar with 7 Taskbar Tweaker http://rammichael.com/?proj=29

Thanks but it's useless for me as I'm on a business machine with restrictions on allowable software installation.