Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Aardwolf 596 days ago
> The model of non-self-interacting gravity is a particle we call a "graviton," and it probably describes reality very well when the gravitation involved is so weak that its self-interaction is undetectable.

Can you please elaborate, the first part of the sentence says graviton is for non-self-interacting gravity, the second part of the sentence says graviton is for self-interacting (if 'its' in 'its self-interaction' refers to the graviton).

I don't intend to nitpick the sentence, just trying to understand the theory and I don't even know if particle means self interaction or the opposite and can't parse it here either...

If the answer is graviton is for non-self-interacting: what is the model for the other case (where gravity does self interact) and what would cause that self interaction if not the graviton?

1 comments

> Can you please elaborate, the first part of the sentence says graviton is for non-self-interacting gravity, the second part of the sentence says graviton is for self-interacting (if 'its' in 'its self-interaction' refers to the graviton).

The point is, we know gravitation does self-interact. But our best model, the graviton, doesn't model self-interaction. So the model is probably accurate in regimes where you'd expect little self-interaction anyways.

Would self-interaction mean something like:

just like the massless photon, the massless graviton would be bent by the gravity of black holes... hence self interaction?

Photon-photon interaction is photon self interaction. Gravity/graviton self interaction then means graviton-graviton interaction. In general relativity, all form of energy would have an effect of gravity, and also react to gravity. Since all matter, including photon and graviton, has energy, then they should self interact.

In QED, photon and photon do interacts too and you can calculate its effect to be small. In GR, you can expect self interaction is small if the space time curvature is small.

(Photon is the particle that mediates QED, and graviton is the hypothetical particle that mediates gravity.)