Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by llamaimperative 605 days ago
You don't need to live in China or have family there to be worried about China: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-arrested-operating-illega...

People should avoid giving more data to China out of sheer principle, regardless of their personal attachment to China.

2 comments

> People should avoid giving more data to China out of sheer principle

Or self preservation.

Every intelligence agency collects blackmail. The obvious targets are those in high office. But sometimes you need disposable randos to e.g. collect intelligence or place assets. Being able to pass blackmail to an operative who can use it to convince e.g. a farmer to give them pictures of a silo or Air Force base (under the guise of commercial espionage for a domestic competitor or whatever) is valuable.

Agreed, and I know Opera is Chinese-owned, but Opera's web site still lists their headquarters as Norway. Doesn't this still make them a Norwegian company, with some safeguards against abuse? Not sure if any EU laws might also come into play.
> Doesn't this still make them a Norwegian company

No. It's a Chinese company with an office in Oslo (in addition to China) [1].

Had they run it as an independent subsidiary there might have been a claim that it remains Norwegian. But they haven't and so it isn't.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opera_(company)#Acquisition_an...

I think foreign intelligence services are perfectly comfortable "navigating" laws. Obviously every company is vulnerable to this, but it sure is preferable not to have ownership concentrated in a country where all corporations are de facto extensions of the state itself.