Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chgs 600 days ago
I pay for Spotify streaming and I strongly suspect I could buy every song I’ve listened to and save a lot of money

Perhaps Spotify overheads are too high, perhaps that 70% goes to the wrong people.

Certainly in my view the disbursement is very wrong. I spend £20 a month and listen for one hour a day. if I listen to 4 artists equally (either by number or by seconds) then each of those 4 artists should get 70% of £5 a month each.

That’s not how it works though, and I fund artists I’m not interested in and never listen to, who are listened to for 8 hours a day by others

1 comments

> Perhaps Spotify overheads are too high,

Its says 70% of revenues, so even if they reduced overheads and their profit to zero artists would only get 42% more.

> perhaps that 70% goes to the wrong people.

Possibly. Who are the wrong and right people? Some people get a lot:

https://loudandclear.byspotify.com/

If I spend £10 and listen to only Lily Allen I would expect her to get £7

If you spent £10 and listen to only Taylor Swift I’d expect her to also get £7

Howver I believe if I listen to Lily for 10 hours in the month and you listen to Taylor for 90 hours, then instead Taylor gets 90% of the £14 (£12.80) and Lily gets 10% (£1.40)

That doesn’t seem right.