Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fanf2 609 days ago
Peer review is done for free by academics. The publisher does not contribute to peer review.
1 comments

The publisher does often assist with coordinating the peer review process which is a nontrivial task. I'm not saying this in itself necessitates everything else surrounding the publishing ecosystem, but I don't think it's accurate to say the publisher does not contribute.
In my editor experience the assistance is minimal at best. Editors (almost all upaid) assess suitability of manuscripts, find the reviewers and handle all communication.