Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cynicalsecurity 612 days ago
Why would Italy have anything called Piracy Shield? Is it located in the West or in China?
4 comments

To combat illegal sports streaming and betting. On a deeper level it is to combat major crime organisations on a financial level. Italy actually has a lot of initiatives to do these things, though some obviously work better than others. One of the better is how every budget has to has through a government service, to tack illegal activities both internally and across borders. Many EU countries have various things like this, though in Italy is far more focused on the financial aspects because Italy obviously has a big past of organised crime to the point where these organisations rivalled the nation station.

The piracy shield is terribly implemented of course and does a lot of harm to things it wasn’t necessarily meant to target. Part of this is because the law itself is rather terrible and has already undergone multiple changes and amendments, but part of it is also that Italy has a rather tough “no fucks” policy toward major tech companies.

there is no deeper level, they want to stop soccer streaming, simple as that.
> On a deeper level it is to combat major crime organisations on a financial level.

Lol no, on a deeper level it is to preserve mafia's profits in the soccer business.

The real question is: how did you come to believe 'the West' does not censor?
And this is meant to insinuate what exactly?
I find it curious how people in 'the West' fail to recognize the extend of propaganda by their own media, corporations and governments, while they seem to have no qualms attributing the same machinations to the rest of the world.
Oh yes so curious indeed, you should try and look inwards some day curious person, who knows what curiosity you'll find on your curiously curious adventures.
that the west has no moral superiority over china
There is a vast difference between "oppressing people who dare to mention a certain historical event that the party doesn't like" and "blocking some malware or illegal downloads on the DNS level". I hope you're not being serious when you're equating them.
you sure the west is not doing that "oppressing people who dare to mention a certain historical event that the party doesn't like" bit ? think again
Given your evidence of zero, no.
And has "the west" proclaimed this imaginary "moral superiority"?
They said that in the TV. We are free living in a free country. /s
If I recall correctly they were also the first Western country (or the first country overall outside of China) to implement lockdowns, at a time when everyone was saying that we couldn’t do them and that lockdowns could only happen in a country like China.
They were the first Western country to get a COVID-19 outbreak.
All European countries censor the Internet to some extent.

OpenDNS is not operating in France and Portugal, for example. There are many other cases.

Sometimes it's because of piracy, sometimes it's because of terrorism, sometimes it's because it allows voters to post comments about immigration or vaccine policy, or criticism about certain Western allies committing war crimes and ethnic cleansing, etc.