Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Gigachad 604 days ago
A proprietary format would allow doing anything, without having to worry about how other programs will support it.

There’s a conflict between what is needed to simply display images, and what is needed for an ideal editable document.

A web browser doesn’t need the complexity of non destructive Boolean operations, but an editor program does. It can all be exported to SVG at the end once it doesn’t need to be edited anymore. Things like variable thickness outlines can just be turned in to filled Bézier curve shapes that happen to be the shape of the outline.
2 comments
prmoustache 604 days ago
You don't have to have a proprietary format to do that.

You are doing the mistake of associating open format with standard format, which really are orthogonal concepts. Open format means the format specification is published under an open license. A standard format is one whose specification is maintained by a standards organization/body/consortium. It happens that most open formats are or end up being maintained by a standard body out of convenience[1] and because people often publish them in the open with the hope it will also be used by others but it doesn't have to be. You as developer of application foo can publish the spec of your .bar format on foo's website under an open license and do the fuck you want with it while not being limited by the potential slowness of a standard governing body.

[1] mostly to avoid multiple incompatible forked versions of the format being used with the same name and confusing others.

link
jasaldivara 603 days ago
I don't think they are saying "proprietary" as in "secret, closed source", but just as in "custom format" that is built around one particular application.
link
ltlnx 603 days ago
The problem with SVG is the different demands between browser vendors and graphic editors. Browsers for example don't need pages to be in SVG, but it's unavoidable for proper graphic design tools. That makes the advancement of an open format a lot harder, and AFAIK Inkscape devs have thought of extending SVG into their own format (in a talk at LGM).
link
bobajeff 603 days ago
I suspect you could achieve a similar result with a standard specification format for vector graphics. You just need to be open to extensions for prototyping features. See open *OpenRaster.

The issue with using SVG is it's not meant for use as data exchange in vector graphics editors but for web publishing.

* https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenRaster

link