Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by milo256 609 days ago
Huh? In what world is a hyperloop going maybe 700mph comparable to a spacecraft reentering from orbit at 17,000mph? Also, maybe there's something I'm missing but spacecraft can and do renter from orbit intact, thus proving that this problem is solvable even when the forces at play are orders of magnitude greater. Apply your safety argument to passenger airliners or even ordinary trains and you'll see that they are also "impossible to make safety guarantees" for.
1 comments

> In what world is a hyperloop going maybe 700mph comparable to a spacecraft reentering from orbit at 17,000mph?

In that case, the air can just "go around" the space craft. Try pushing down a syringe with the end capped. Bet you can't do it. Now imagine that at 700 mph; you will get a lot of heat and destruction. No heat shielding will save you.

> Apply your safety argument to passenger airliners or even ordinary trains and you'll see that they are also "impossible to make safety guarantees" for.

See sibling comment.

You have a strange idea of what a hyperloop is. nobody says it has to be sealed around the edges like a syringe plunger.