[rogerbinns]

My experience has been that developers using a gui make better commits. It is far easier to see what the changes are, see unintended code changes, make a more useful message and only pick a relevant subset of changed hunks.

The command line only folks tend to do 'git commit -a' or equivalent and have messy noisy commits.

Yes a highly skilled developer at the top of their game, paying attention to every detail and pumped full of caffeine is far less likely to do that, but they are rare.