Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by unsnap_biceps 614 days ago
woah, what do you mean by calling it fraud? Have you actually had companies come after you legally due to an email alias?
3 comments

I'm not GP, but I've had transitions denied while attempting to purchase something because the retailer's code flagged my email address as suspicious because it contained their name in it.
Haven't had that happen to me, but I did get asked by a clueless support rep from $VERY_BIG_MULTINATIONAL_CORPORATION whether I was also an employee due to their company name appearing in my email address. (Coincidentally I used to consult for that company.) Long story short I set them straight rather than trying to parlay their ignorance to my advantage.

The most shocking thing was that I was calling them regarding an issue in which they required me to prove my identity, and yet the person I spoke with didn't seem to be well versed in security measures.

Also: I use a separate alias for every company (and sometimes individual) I deal with. In the 25 or so years I've been doing this, so far I'm up to over 1,000 aliases.

I've always knew at least some companies would do that so I just use slight variations on their names. Never had an issue.
I had this happen as well. I responded with a long rant, which apparently proved my humanity.
Linode did this to me.
Just another data point, I've had the same issue with some vendors.
Conversations caused by the odd looking email address can often get very nasty.

This is why I also like how iCloud does with their hide my mail feature; there’s nothing suspicious about the email you give out.

It only has to be unique. It's easy to find out who you gave it to by looking at the very first email.

ROT13 or the date in base36 (to keep it short) might help when you need to spell your email address over the phone. Today is oaf@example.com.

Hiding information behind a non-standard encoding is a really smart idea.

I will update my technique to use incorporate this method, thanks!

Unix epoch `date +%s` still only requires 6 characters. I really like your idea.
I have not had anyone accuse me of fraud yet, but I have had email addresses rejected because they too obviously contained the company name in them.
Samsung does this for example! You can't register a Samsung account if your email contains the word "Samsung"...
I think this might be a lazy attempt to protect users from scammers trying to impersonate the company.

There are people that will read an email from "SamsungCeo@gmail.com" and think it's actually from the owner of the company...

I would venture a guess that there is an equal proportion of company executives who would think that creating and using an email address like 'CompanyCeo@gmail.com' was completely fine - an awareness of internet scams is not correlated with business acumen!
Also frustrating when a company adds it after you register, e.g. Spotify allowed me to use spotify@ at one point, now I can't register anything with that word in .