[ben_w]

You need the criteria in advance to even know if the thing is impossible.

We don't know the extent of our ignorance about intelligence.

> I think something that only learns to reproduce text, can not become an intelligent actor.

> It's necessary to act in an environment with Feedback.

Ok, but text adventures are a thing, so that doesn't rule out learning from text.

And all RHLF has humans as part of the environment and giving feedback (that's the H and the F in RLHF).