Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by david38 616 days ago
If I have to pay to clean up your mess to live in a world the way it was before you polluted it, it’s a subsidy
2 comments

Before fossil fuels our cities were ankle-deep in horse shit, and when a horse died the owner dumped the carcass in the river. Some level of pollution is in inescapable price of civilization. We shouldn't be reckless or wanton about it but it's unreasonable and uneconomic to ever clean up all of the mess.
All or nothing fallacy. The argument is not to eliminate pollution, the argument is to stop generating greenhouse gases. You can already see the effects of climate change and it's guaranteed to get worse.

I don't understand why you're making excuses for carbon pollution.

But you don’t know the cleanup cost yet, so how can you put a dollar amount on the subsidy?
There are estimates for the social cost of carbon. It isn't super exact.