[thunky]

> Until we can get into the criminal's brain we can't know the extent to which they thought it through.

Sure we can, based on their actions. For example, we know that the guy that killed 60 people in Vegas planned it out ahead of time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Las_Vegas_shooting#Prepar....

I'm not the one saying that the penalty works as a deterrent. It probably didn't in this case since the guy killed himself. Although he may have preferred death to a life in prison.

[paulcole]

Congrats on picking the most extreme example possible.

What about a situation where someone kills their wife after work one day? How will you know if he had thought about it for a while or just snapped? Obviously you will look at the evidence and see if there was clear evidence of planning or not. But if there's not how can you be confident in whether it was planned?

> I'm not the one saying that the penalty works as a deterrent.

Good, because it doesn't.

[thunky]

I never said we know in every instance. And the death penalty isn't applied in every instance either.

> What about a situation where someone kills their wife after work one day? > Obviously you will look at the evidence and see if there was clear evidence of planning or not

Right, and in this court can choose not to execute him based on this uncertainty.