Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ruthmarx 623 days ago
There is no illusion, and brain damage has no bearing on free will.

Free will is simply you making a choice, that's it.

If you want to argue about what 'you' means, feel free, but it doesn't really change anything here.

1 comments

What is "choice"? Is it simply executing one of a set of possibilities? If you take such a general definition of free will, then a slot machine is manifesting it's free will to deny you a payout.
Making a decision either on impulse, intuition, or rational preferences.

> Is it simply executing one of a set of possibilities? If you take such a general definition of free will, then a slot machine is manifesting it's free will to deny you a payout.

Sure, or even just a dice. Except that's a rather silly definition of free will since it omits the 'will' part, i.e. thought.