|
> How did we let discord take over is a mystery to me, or rather a tragedy. I think I'm reasonably technically competent, and I also dislike Discord's issues with privacy, data sovereignty, siloing information away from the open web, etc. But you know what I think whenever I click a Matrix link, or IRC? I just don't want to deal with it. You get a list of apps you've never heard of, some of which may not be feature-complete, some with more than one version, some which are advertised using words like "GNOME", "Rust", "Qt5", and "C++" that have no meaning or relation to actually using them as a chat app, and all of which I guess are different and would need to be tried and learned separately. Then picking and clicking one tries to open an outside program which probably isn't installed and I don't want to install because I don't really know/care what it is. And if at that point, out of the dozen or so app options it showed you, you happened to choose one with a web version like Element, and you figure out you can click the "Continue in your browser" button out of the four or five unexplained buttons that pop up as a result ("XDG-Open", "Cancel", "FlatHub", "Download", and "Continue in Browser")— You get a static screen that shows just enough message history to not be useful, with a confusing UI you can't seem to interact with, hidden behind a login wall that still hasn't really explained what in the Internet tubes you're actually looking at. E.G.: https://matrix.to/#/#invidious:matrix.org If you try to Google "What is Matrix"— You get pages about math. So then you Google "What is Matrix chat". And all the results harp on using words like "open network", "decentralised", "protocol", "real-time communication", "open standard", "federated"— Which, again, may be technically interesting if you're into that, but doesn't actually have anything to do with how it directly serves the user as a chat app and how you can use it or sign up for it. It takes way too many clicks, and you get bombarded with way too much information… To still not end up using the app, and in fact end up more confused than before about what a "Matrix" even is. Let's say you lose 15% of incoming users at each step. That rapidly scares off most of the mainstream, before they've even tried it. Maybe Matrix and Element are great. But it just seems like such an ordeal. Compare that with Discord. You click a link. And then either you're already in the server, or it has a single text box and a single button you click to funnel you through making an account and joining the server. It doesn't try to convince you to install a Desktop app until you're already fully using it in the web version. You get clear answers and reasons to use it if you search "What is Discord" or go to the website. It doesn't overwhelm you with options and then hound you with technical explainers that you didn't ask for. IRC goes the other way in usability. People want voice chat, message history, different channels in the same "server", PM channels, etc. /rant |