Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by flutas 625 days ago
> The resources of Wordpress.org and the Wordpress Foundation should not be leverage in this dispute.

I honestly wonder if it crosses any legal boundaries. From what I can tell, it's essentially the non-profit acting on commands from the for-profit.

Basically the equivalent in my mind to a "in-kind donation".
2 comments
that_guy_iain 624 days ago
To me, I think it's more that it shows they're one entity and then it is a massive issue about the tax write offs Automattic will have been claiming for years. But, I guess we'll see because WP Engine is going to come out swinging on this. They have to.

There is also the fact that WP Engine sponsored a WordPress Foundation event and then was kicked out of it because of this dispute. The WordPress foundation accepted 75k knowing what WP Engine was doing and then didn't honour the deal.

link
safety1st 624 days ago
This is also the most shocking thing to me, that Matt seems to be very blasé about using Automattic and the foundation more or less interchangeably and in a very public way to further his goals. So other than the tax writeoffs what was the point of creating the foundation? Where is this guy's legal counsel? Surely they have to be screaming their heads off right now because from the outside every indication now is that the Foundation is really just an extension of Automattic that exists to dodge taxes and whether it is claiming its nonprofit status legally is now becoming a question mark. This is so far for Matt to have fallen and taken WordPress with him
link
that_guy_iain 624 days ago
> Where is this guy's legal counsel?

They're represented by Perkins Coie. Who, even as someone from the EU who doesn't do any legal stuff, I have heard of and know are very good. I think they'll be kind of loving this mess. Because even though this is a mess, they're going to get paid to deal with the mess.

link
Nemo_bis 624 days ago
> the tax write offs Automattic will have been claiming for years

How? There's exactly zero dollars of donations from Automattic in the Wordpress Foundation financials. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/205...

(It would be quite defensible for Automattic to claim they're donating many millions in-kind every year, but they don't seem to be doing it.)

link
that_guy_iain 624 days ago
They'll be writing off all those contributions 4000 hours is a lot of hours.
link
Nemo_bis 624 days ago
Says who?

https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...

link
that_guy_iain 624 days ago
It’s a guess since they’re keep track of hours of contributions. Development services are services under that irs doc, afaik.
link
Nemo_bis 620 days ago
It doesn't matter that Automattic keeps track. For the contribution to be fiscally relevant, the Foundation needs to keep track and release receips (and presumably report the totals somewhere).
link
kgwgk 624 days ago
If the non-profit is doing something for the benefit of the for-profit it’s the reverse of a donation - unless you really meant a “donation” from the foundation to the company.
link
flutas 624 days ago
> unless you really meant a “donation” from the foundation to the company

Yeah, that's what I meant.

Essentially laundering money through the 501c3 to try and negate taxes. In this case actual money never changed hands, but what is the financial value of cutting off your competitor from the theme/plugin repo?...

Not an insignificant amount.

link
kgwgk 624 days ago
Ah, I misunderstood your "wonder if it crosses any legal boundaries" as "it seems it doesn't" rather than "it seems it does". I completely agree.
link