Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by trimethylpurine 637 days ago
I wouldn't trust those sources. Google funded sources (Wikipedia) and other major political lobby participants shouldn't guide a well formed stance on any topic. Statista's Wikipedia page itself demands for its own deletion due to being a poor and unverifiable source of data.

Outside my window is a line of billboards with digital displays that show the ER wait time at the hospitals beneath them (there are 7 within a 5 mile radius). I can see them without having to actually go to the ER. Maybe I could post a photograph for you somewhere. When I go (I've been over 47 times in my life, or at least that's what I have records for) in this state I've never waited more than 30 minutes, and there's rarely more than 4 or 5 people in the lobby. If you are really having a hard time getting care for your children that's a good reason to move to another state.

All that being said, I can agree with you in some cases. In Los Angeles I waited far longer and I don't blame people living there for believing it's bad everywhere. But in fact, it's common here to have no wait at all. The last time I took my elderly mother in for care (three times in the last week) the wait was for the front counter clerk to get back from the bathroom. The lobby was completely empty of patients. Her circulatory system was imaged. We were in and out within 2 hours.

Most of the hospitals here are owned by an insurance provider, and maybe that helps. I'm not sure, really.

>Actually the US ranks rather poorly in terms of life expectancy

Again, check that you are using reliable sources for your claims. Life expectancy is right around 80 in most civilized countries and the US is right there with Europe.

Keep in mind that large corporations don't like paying for their employees' health care and they don't want you to like the health care system that they are forced to pay for. They want you to get online and rally efforts to vote against it so that it will be as bad as it is in Europe.

I live in both places, and I can say with confidence, you will absolutely pay more (in taxes) for health care in Europe, and the wait for care is often so long that you'll pay for private care anyway. Same doctors, you just skip the long wait if you pay. I'm literally paying for it today for a family member.

I'm not saying the US is perfect, I'm just saying that it's partly socialized, and that if you fill out the forms you can get care, same as in Europe, and at least in some states, it's better.

The overarching reality is that even socialized care requires filling out forms and registering in some system. And the rich still get to go to the front of the line. It's no different in Europe.

1 comments

Possibly true, though too many separate studies and surveys show the inadequacies of American healthcare for me to dismiss them all.

When I last lived in the USA my ACA premium (self-employed, two adults) started at $1,150/mo with $12,000 combined annual deductible, plus a co-pay. I struggled to find doctors who would accept the insurance, and in the US you need a primary care physician to refer to specialists, get diagnostics, etc. After two years of that my premium got raised to $1,450/mo with $14k deductible — prohibitive for me and I will guess most middle-class people. Quality of care fairly poor — doctors and labs missed a critical cardiac condition twice.

I live in Thailand now, where I can walk in to a hospital without a referral, get the tests I need immediately, and pay out of pocket because prices come to 1/5th or less than US prices. Thai hospitals found two urgent conditions missed in the US. I have a catastrophic policy that costs $210/mo for me and my wife, with $500/yr deductible. In a poor developing country that, incidentally, has a lot of immigrants, legal and illegal.

Thailand has socialized health care for citizens. Very cheap but not the best quality of care. If you remove automobile and motorbike collisions (bad in Thailand) the medical outcomes and life expectancies match the US, on average.

Your mileage varies. In the US you can get treatment for some things in the ER. You cannot walk in and get a colonoscopy, or cardiac imaging, which may not seem urgent in the moment but can save your life nevertheless. I prefer not to wait for the heart attack or tumor I may survive if I can get to an ER in time. My father had the same largely genetic conditions and died without insurance, unable to get diagnostic care where he lived.