Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jakey_bakey 641 days ago
> "It has been thought of as many things"

This makes me remember the time I looked at a random book at my university library, and it happened to be a physics book from 1905.

Which was both fascinating and unintentionally hilarious due to it proudly asserting that we knew most of physics now because we knew about atoms, and assuring the plum pudding model as how atoms worked.

n.b. Plum Pudding was the old-school idea that atoms were a positively-charged blob with negative electrons embedded. It was refuted when you measure the radiation scattering patterns off gold foil and discover that, actually, there's an extremely dense nucleus.

1 comments

while I often wonder what part of today's knowledge will appear brutally obsolete for those born in the 2100s
As a physics (and SF) enthusiast, I've come to realize that we've discovered most of the physics that exists, and all of what we can use. This is disappointing for those who yearn for FTL or teleportation, but it's good news when you consider that it creates an impregnable defense against interstellar invasion. Within the limits of modern physics, there remains a great deal to understand and apply, especially in QM because to quote Feynman "there's plenty of room at the bottom". Biology and nanotechnology can still revolutionize human existence.

The key problem humans must grapple with an solve, if we are to make it long-term, is how to harness greater and greater power without destroying ourselves. Nuclear destruction has been a very real option for 80 years. Biological weapons could do the job, too. And of course, climate change looms. For many years I agreed with the thinkers that wish for a "backup plan" for humanity; however, I don't think Mars will do it simply because its environment is even harsher than a post-nuclear holocaust Earth. The important reality that THIS is our home, and we must protect her even if it's hard. Yearning for advanced physics to solve all our problems has the unfortunate side-effect of undermining motivation to solve the problems we have now with the tech we have now. It underlies an unfortunate "disposable planet" attitude that we'd be better off without.

You don't think there's an einstein jr that will come one day and change some fundamental model in the weirdest way that will flip physics on its head again ?