Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by archildress 630 days ago
I hope all the self proclaimed tech libertarians in the audience who hate so called "cancel culture" loved a little laugh at their expense. :)
6 comments

The fact that you don't think people should not be cancelled for saying something stupid doesn't mean that you have to love their jokes or even agree with what they are saying.
Does not laughing constitute "cancelation"?
worse

if someone identifies as funny and you don't laugh you are literally denying their existence

Dreamforce is mostly sales guys. They’ll be happy to laugh at the nerds but for what it’s worth people usually enjoy this kind of thing in tech. It’s mostly in delivery.

We had a comedian around once and he was doing a bit. Asked for volunteers and I went up obviously. He asks me what I do and I’m like “software haha like most people here I suppose” and he goes “yeah, but specifically how does your thing work” which is a transparent frame up job but what are you gonna do so I have to explain freaking ad tech in front of the audience and he roasts me proper.

Pretty hilarious. We got a kick out of it. Loads of fun.

It needs to be funny though, and the quotes in the article were a miss for me...
Huh?

They were a little funny.

I mean the guy's right. 45,000 "trailblazers"?

Not to put too fine a point on it, but that's like, what? 40-45 Marine Corps battalions?

Being right doesn't mean it's funny though... Call me old fashioned but isn't the point of comedy to be funny, not correct?

What do I know though, it's been years since I've found any standup comic very funny, and most comedy movies just make me groan. I'm no expert on what is or isn't funny, I just find it odd that you defend the humor here by pointing out its correctness.

FWIW I've never heard of this guy nor heard any of his jokes.

There's a shred of truth in every joke.
Sure, but "fire is hot" isn't much of a joke.
Only if I’m the one on fire, then it’s relative.
I guess part of it not being funny is it feels alittle over done.

I can't imagine it's the first time you've heard that sentiment.

I quite like John Mulaney but I do kind of agree, these are rather contrived insights. That being said, I also think that delivery is part of what makes a joke land and we're just reading a few select bits after the fact as opposed to watching Mulaney deliver them onstage. I remember being introduced to some Mitch Hedberg bits over IM some years back, followed the next day by them reciting those bits, and it didn't click at all until they popped in a VHS tape (yes it was that long ago) and I saw Hedberg anxiously weaving back and forth, heard him mumbling and elongating his phrases. I wouldn't say Mulaney's in the same league, but I don't think it's unfair to say this contributes.
Well, 40 Marine Corps battalions could probably blaze a few trails...
How could reading one-sentence snippets out of a standup comedian’s set inside a news article a few mornings later not retain the original humor?
Totally 100%
Yes, if any group is known for their good humored nature it's anti-woke libertarian tech-bros.