[zachwill]

Pay the guy his money, but man, that design is pretty bad.

[lysol]

The one on Reddit is fairly generic. The real one on the site is downright ugly: http://eligibleapp.com/

[cluda01]

Could you please elaborate as to why you think so? I'm not trying to be a contrarian here. I'm asking because I'm a backend engineer so my opinions on design admittedly isn't very sophisticated.

[incongruity]

It's not so much bad, per se, as it is just... well... inert. There's no there, there.

[learc83]

Presumably there would have been some further iterations and back and forth between the client and the designer had the contract continued.