Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chris_wot 643 days ago
ChatGPT is remarkably good at removing bullshit, whereas this just gives an error.

I asked it to rewrite the following:

“This thesis critically interrogates how masculinist practices of breakdancing offers a site for the transgression of gendered norms. Drawing on my own experiences as a female within the male-dominated breakdancing scene in Sydney, first as a spectator, then as an active crew member, this thesis questions why so few female participants engage in this creative space, and how breakdancing might be the space to displace and deterritorialise gender. I use analytic autoetthnography and interviews with scene members in collaboration with theoretical frameworks offered by Deleuze and Guttari, Butler, Bourdieu and other feminist and post-structuralist philosophers, to critically examine how the capacities of bodies are constituted and shaped in Sydney's breakdancing scene, and to also locate the potentiality for moments of transgression. In other words, I conceptualize the breaking body as not a 'body' constituted through regulations and assumptions, but as an assemblage open to new rhizomatic connections. Breaking is a space that embraces difference, whereby the rituals of the dance not only augment its capacity to deterritorialize the body, but also facilitate new possibilities for performativities beyond the confines of dominant modes of thought and normative gender construction. Consequently, this thesis attempts to contribute to what I perceive as a significant gap in scholarship on hip-hop, breakdancing, and autoethnographic explorations of Deleuze-Guattarian theory.”

It gave me:

“This thesis examines how breakdancing, often seen as a male-dominated activity, challenges traditional gender norms. Based on my personal experience as a woman in Sydney’s breakdancing community—first as a spectator and then as a participant—I explore why so few women take part and how breakdancing can be a space to challenge and redefine gender roles. Using my own story and interviews with others in the scene, along with ideas from philosophers like Deleuze, Guattari, Butler, and Bourdieu, I look at how people’s bodies and identities are shaped within this culture. I argue that breakdancing allows for breaking away from conventional ideas about gender, offering new ways for people to express themselves. This thesis aims to fill a gap in research about hip-hop, breakdancing, and how Deleuze-Guattarian theory can be applied to personal experiences in this space.”

1 comments

I got

"Yo, check it: I'm a chick who breakdances in Sydney's sausage fest scene. Gonna ramble about why there ain't many ladies busting moves and how we can flip gender norms on their head. Gonna throw in some fancy philosophy words to sound smart, talk about my own experiences, and interview some homies. Basically, I'm saying breakdancing can mess with gender roles and let people express themselves however they want. Oh, and I'm filling a gap in research 'cause apparently no one's thought to mix hip-hop and fancy French philosophy before. Boom."

I didn't expect to actually respect it more after the transformation ("I'm saying breakdancing can mess with gender roles and let people express themselves however they want." -- okay, that can be thought-provoking), but I guess that shows the trouble with academic prose selecting for obfuscation.

Related classic, "How to deconstruct almost anything": http://www.fudco.com/chip/deconstr.html

I got almost the same thing:

> Yo, check it: I'm a chick who breakdances in Sydney's sausage fest scene. Gonna ramble about why there ain't many ladies busting moves and how we can flip gender norms on their head. Gonna throw in some fancy philosophy words to sound smart, talk about my own experiences, and interview some homies. Basically, I'm saying breakdancing can mess with gender roles and open up new ways of being. Oh, and I'm filling a gap in research 'cause apparently no one's thought to mix hip-hop and French philosophy before. Groundbreaking stuff, right?

So it's close to deterministic but not quite.

I also occurs to me to ask whether this is a fixed point. Close, but not quite. I put that output in, and get:

> Yo, I'm a breakdancing chick in Sydney's sausage fest. Gonna blab about why there's no ladies and how to fix it. Throwing in big words to sound smart, talking about myself, and chatting with my crew. Basically, breakdancing can fuck with gender roles. Oh, and I'm the first genius to mix hip-hop and French philosophy. Revolutionary, innit?

Iterating again:

> Oi, Sydney's b-girl scene's a sausage fest. Gonna bitch about the lack of chicks and how to fix it. Throwing in fancy words to sound smart, jerking myself off, and circle-jerking with my crew. Breakdancing messes with gender norms or whatever. Oh, and I'm totally the first genius to mix hip-hop and Foucault. Groundbreaking shit, mate.