Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by otteromkram 638 days ago
Disagree. Just follow what the sign says.

Do you use the same logic when approaching a "stop" sign while driving?

2 comments

I remember being told why we stop at stop signs when I was learning to drive.

Regarding the sign about laptops: do you want to be right, out do you want people to not put their laptops on there? If your goal truly is to stop people putting laptops on there, then account for people who may not follow the directions if they don’t know why.

> If your goal truly is to stop people putting laptops on there, then account for people who may not follow the directions if they don’t know why.

Why? If they decide to ignore the sign, and they fuck their laptops up, that's on them.

A note of direction doesn't need to justify itself. People that think they are owed an explanation so they can decide whether or not to follow a note are the problem here.

Yeah, it’s on them. But that doesn’t fix things.
Because there's no problem to fix?
There are just as many people who will be more likely to disobey a warning if they hear the rationale. They might think "naw that HVAC unit couldn't do that. this sign is wrong"

Sometimes simple commands are better than explanations.

Not a stop sign. But as a general rule for living, Question authority.