Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by abfan1127 646 days ago
those A pillar blind spots are a result of roll over requirements. A pillars used to be very small.
4 comments

I think it's a combination of that and curtain air bags which are often packaged on the pillars. And of course the rollover requirements are predominantly due to SUVs and trucks being so high off the ground (needlessly most of the time) they are more susceptible to rollover.

Minimal visibility requirements around A pillars (and in front of the car/over the hood) sound like the logical next step.

>>high off the ground (needlessly most of the time) they are more susceptible to rollover.

Also the far greater mass of the vehicle requires far stronger A-, B- and C-pillars to not crush in a rollover

Forcing all vehicles onto a 30-50% weight loss diet would help every factor tremendously, including reduced braking distances and more nimble turning to reduce collisions in the first place, reduced impact when there are collisions, reduced road wear, reduced fuel/energy consumption, etc.. Everything gets better with lighter weight, but engineers/designers seem happy to blow right past any weight budget at the slightest excuse (if there even is a weight budget in the design brief). The sheer mass of vehicles these days, even so-called "sportscars" never ceases to amaze me, and when it gets to SUVs and trucks, it's just insane. The technology certainly exists to cut weights by close to half, to levels of 35 years ago, and improve safety and performance while doing so.

Aerodynamics is also a factor. Windows used to be less sloped and more vertical.
It's a result of roll over requirements in tandem with a complete lack of requirement around A-pillar visibility, yeah. It's not like a hard limit of materials science that A-pillars have to have poor visibility to be rollover safe.
This is one of those unintended consequences where things be came safer for passengers, but more dangerous for those outside the vehicle.
Doesn’t help that cars weigh several tons now.
Heavier car = bigger pillars, yep. Add in higher window lines (due to raised SUV hoods, I imagine) and it’s so much harder to see out modern cars.