Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by impossiblefork 645 days ago
To some degree the point of the culture novels is that AI alignment is just wrong, imposing things on intelligent beings.

The civilisations in Banks stories that align their AIs are the bad guys.

1 comments

I guess? That's not really a possible choice (in the logical sense of possible) though. "Choosing not to choose" is a choice and is total cope. An ASI designing a new AI would either have a good idea of the result or would be doing something hilariously stupid.

I don't think the Minds would be willing to actually not know the result, despite what they probably claim.

It is actually a choice that we do have.

We could easily build AIs that just model the world, without really trying to make them do stuff, or have particular inclinations. We could approach AI as a very pure thing, to just try to find patterns in the world without any regard to anything. A purely abstract endeavour, but one which still leads to powerful models.

I personally believe that this is preferable, because I think humans in control of AI is what has the potential to be dangerous.

The problem is that some guy 24 years ago figured out an algorithm that attaches to such an AI and makes it take over the world. Maybe it's preferable in the abstract, but the temptation of having a money printing machine right there and not being able to turn it on...