Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AlotOfReading 649 days ago
Happens even with my personal GitHub account across multiple browsers/operating systems.
2 comments

Counter-anecdote. I cannot even remember the last time I was asked to log into Github, at the office, at home, on my laptop, and even on my phone.

Do you perhaps have a browser setting that nukes cookies/session data by any chance? Or perhaps use a VPN that might be tripping some sort of account protection mechanism?

Counter-counter, I share his experience as well and don't have any of those things. Just bog standard Chrome with no extensions.

What I do have, and I expect is relevant: frequent ~weeklong gaps where I don't access GitHub at all in this browser profile. I assume there's some medium-lived token that's refreshed when you access the site.

My experience is similar to yours, though I seem to have to login every other week or so it feels like (maybe it’s once a month I don’t know).

This feeling could also be exasperated though since while I only use a personal GitHub account, I access it frequently from the browser and app on numerous devices.

I can definitively say though that I need to login more than twice a year on any one device.

Mine too. It wasn't always like this, but nowadays if I haven't accessed the site in a handful of days there's a good chance I'm logged out when I go. And it requires logging in, then mobile 2FA. It's very annoying.
Just to put this out there - but this doesn't actually sound that unreasonable.

Your tokens/session should expire at some point. We can argue over what might be a reasonable duration, but it definitely should expire.

What might be going on is if you visit the site/app it renews the token/session if it's still valid. So if you are relatively active on GH, you will stay logged in - otherwise you will eventually be logged out.

Just guessing, but all of this does seem reasonable. There's a lot your Github account can do, including a lot of damage to you and any organizations you are part of.

Totally agree with all of that, and still find it (perhaps irrationally!) annoying when it happens.