Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by alephnerd 659 days ago
St Catherine's Monastery is not a business
2 comments

I mean, if you want to argue it's a Non Profit, not a business, go ahead, but I'm not particularly interested in fitting modern tax code and business rules to an entity that has existed for 1500 years.

The organization has existed and has had a need to find funding for it's activities. Since the question was about 'state' run entities, the goal of "making a profit" seemed not particular salient.

Honestly, I thought the more contentious part of this claim was going to be if the Church of Sinai constituted a state.

> I thought the more contentious part of this claim was going to be if the Church of Sinai constituted a state

That is not as contentious, because it's basically autocephalous/self governing.

It's always been a couple dozen loners in the Sinai peninsula maintaining self sufficiency, which is why I don't find it a good example - as there are plenty of similarly old and continuous organizations, but never truly scaled.

Oh well, guess there's nothing you can learn from it then