Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by malermeister 656 days ago
Was it free speech when he banned a bunch of leftists for disagreeing with his views?
2 comments

No (I have no idea who he has banned or not) but that sounds like a powertrip!
Not just leftists, but also journalists critical of him: https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/x-journalist-ban-elon-mus...

His so-called free-speech absolutism is a sham and he does not deserve the benefit of doubt on this.

I dont believe he is altruistic - his actions in this instance is however positive and i enjoy seeing that.
He didn't ban any of those people:

> All the accounts were restored in a few hours

What state were they restored to? If they were accessible, why did they have to be restored?

If you're going to argue "a ban doesn't count if it's reversed after a couple of hours", what's the threshold? Could Elon ban people for a week without it counting as a ban? What if it happens repeatedly?

If these accounts were banned due to censorship they'd have stayed banned. There are plenty of accounts that were shut down on Twitter that are still disabled today.
And you know that how exactly? Do you work at Twitter? Are you responsible for banning/restoring accounts?

You're making broad statements and assumptions that don't align with reality. The accounts were banned. You don't know why they were banned or restored.

And I disagree with him only allowing right wing radicals and banning left wing radicals.