Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cabbageicefruit 650 days ago
I’d love to see the numbers on this. I suspect that the middle class families buying a rental to Airbnb are largely inconsequential to the housing crisis compared to the corporations buying thousands of homes to cash in on rent for the rest of eternity.
4 comments

Anecdotally, I can say in Florida it’s people renting them out and not living in them. The locals are priced out.

I can afford it, but non tech/banking (the normal people) have moved inland to much worse spots. I only have 2 live-in neighbors on my floor of 8 units; the rest is Airbnb/Some guy who bought the unit to ‘invest’.

I talk with the owners because they occasionally need my physical presence to do something. But all these units would have been families - like they were in the early 2010s.

It might depend on the city but this was recommended recently

https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/video/9.6428660

their claim. Developers built to the market, the market being people wanting an investment rental property. The prices got so high that no one can afford to rent them so investors are losing money. It used to be, mortgage payment = $x. rent = $x+($500-$1000) but now it's rent = $x-($500-$1000). Further, they aren't sellable because they were never designed to be a good place to live long term.

at least that's my summary.

They didn't explain if all this is true why the prices haven't dropped 30-80% to the price that people might be willing to buy things they don't really want. As in "hey, this place is way smaller than I want but the price is really low and the location is great". As it is now it's more like "this place as way smaller than I want and even if I could afford it it's not worth the price"

I'm curious if the same thing happened in other cities.

Housing market is inelastic. Small changes in supply have outsized impact on price.
At the height of it, entire buildings were emptied out or built for short term rentals in the largest US cities.