[dbspin]

Worth noting that aphantasia doesn't necessarily extend to dreams. Anecdotally - I have pretty severe aphantasia (I can conjure milisecond glimpses of barely tangible imagery that I can't quite perceive before it's gone - but only since learning that visualisation wasn't a linguistic metaphor). I can't really simulate object rotation. I can't really 'picture' how things will look before they're drawn / built etc. However I often have highly vivid dream imagery. I also have excellent recognition of faces and places (e.g.: can't get lost in a new city). So there clearly is a lot of preconscious visualisation and image matching going on in some aphantasia cases, even where the explicit visual screen is all but absent.

[lokimedes]

I fabulate about this in another comment below:

> Many people with aphantasia reports being able to visualize in their dreams, meaning that they don't lack the ability to generate visuals. So it may be that the [aphantasia] brain has an affinity to rely on the abstract representation when "thinking", while dreaming still uses the "stable diffusion mode".

(I obviously don't know what I'm talking about, just a fellow aphant)

[dbspin]

Obviously we're all introspecting here - but my guess is that there's some kind of cross talk in aphantasic brains between the conscious narrating semantic brain and the visual module. Such that default mode visualisation is impaired. It's specifically the loss of reflexive consciousness that allows visuals to emerge. Not sure if this is related, but I have pretty severe chronic insomnia, and I often wonder if this in part relates to the inability to drift off into imagery.

[drowsspa]

Yeah. In my head it's like I'm manipulating SVG paths instead of raw pixels

[zimpenfish]

Pretty much the same for me. My aphantasia is total (no images at all) but still ludicrously vivid dreams and not too bad at recognising people and places.