[dleink]

That sounds like a dream. I have a distinct memory of doing in class writing in 3rd grade where the teacher would force us to redo it if there were mistakes and give minimal feedback. As far as my 3rd grade memory can recall, I rewrote it several thousands times and never got it all the way right.

[pastage]

It was a dream for ME. I always think of that teacher when I do code reviews. The important part is how you manage to communicate things effectively. I had one friend who never managed to get better and complained, not loudly but it was clear it felt like hell to him.

I do not know if the instructions would have worked for you, maybe it just worked on the ones that really saw a need to improve in this specific task. I know most people missunderstand me when I give out instructions.