[dominicrose]

What about a pure function that can take anything that has an age as input? Well obviously that wouldn't work for a cat but it's just an example. It requires typescript and I'm not sure how to name the file it would go in, but I think it's interesting to consider this duck-typing style.

    function isAdult({age}: {age: int}) {
        return age >= 18
    }

ps: I replaced const by function because I don't like the IDE saying I can't use something before it is defined. It's not a bug it's an early feature of javascript to be able to use a function before it is defined. Code is just easier to read when putting the caller above the callee.

[vips7L]

That wouldn’t be object oriented. In OO you tend to want to ask an object about itself, Yegor talks a bit about this in his book Elegant Objects.

What you are proposing is just functions or data-oriented programming; which is fine if that’s your thing, but I’d be weary because of the reasons you outline above. Can a book be an adult? What about a tv show? Or recipe from the 9th century? isAdult really only applies to users and really belongs on that object.