[486sx33]

No, because the entire point of a tip is to reward great service

What we should be doing is tipping better for great service and tipping less or not at all for poor service!

[basch]

You tip the person who pours you a drip coffee or a tap beer, but not the person who lugs an 80lb box to your doorstep. Would you advocate eliminating the $1 handing someone a cup tip, because it is expected service and not "above and beyond?"