Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by api 679 days ago
Infosec suffers from a huge cargo cult and mindless sticky meme problem because so few people actually understand it.

There are still admins who block all ICMP because of the “ping of death,” a Windows bug from either the late 1990s or 2000s. They don’t know this though. They just heard that ICMP is “dangerous.”

People also don’t use IPv6 because they think NAT is a security feature.

I guess it’s similar to baseless health fears and happens whenever people don’t really understand a domain. You get a proliferation of lore that is just repeated.

3 comments

> People also don’t use IPv6 because they think NAT is a security feature.

Literally had a sales engineer parrot this at me awhile back. I had to point out that the service they were offering was on the open internet. It only got worse from there. Le sigh...

Windows had an ICMP CVE last year and also just released a patch for an IPv6 CVE. OpenSSH on Linux had a CVE recently too. Security in depth is reasonable and not baseless.
In either the case of infosec or health, the idea at work is that you can ensure that something is good simply by identifying and removing all that is bad. ... and everyone feels free to determine for themselves what is bad with no deep understanding of the involved systems.