Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ivankuz 679 days ago
It was the latest nginx at the time. I actually found a rather obscure issue on Github that touches on this problem, for those who are curious:

https://github.com/kubernetes/ingress-nginx/issues/1681#issu...

> We discovered a related issue where we have multiple ssl-passthrough upstreams that only use different hostnames. [...] nginx-ingress does not inspect the connection after the initial handshake - no matter if the HOST changes.

That was 5-ish years ago though. I hope there are better ways than the cert hack now.
1 comments
ploxiln 679 days ago
That's a misunderstanding in your use of this ingress-controller "ssl-passthrough" feature.

> This feature is implemented by intercepting all traffic on the configured HTTPS port (default: 443) and handing it over to a local TCP proxy. This bypasses NGINX completely and introduces a non-negligible performance penalty.

> SSL Passthrough leverages SNI and reads the virtual domain from the TLS negotiation

So if you want multiple subdomains handled by the same ip address and using the same wildcard TLS cert, and chrome re-uses the connection for a different subdomain, nginx needs to handle/parse the http, and http-proxy to the backends. In this ssl-passthrough mode it can only look at the SNI host in the initial TLS handshake, and that's it, it can't look at the contents of the traffic. This is a limitation of http/tls/tcp, not of nginx.

link
ivankuz 679 days ago
Thank you very much for such a clear explanation of what's happening. Yeah, I sensed that it's not a limitation of the nginx per-se, as it was asked not to do ssl termination, hence of course it can't extract header from the scrambled bytes. As I needed it to do grpc through asp.net, it is a kestrel requirement to do ssl termination that forced me to use the ssl-passthrough, which probably comes from a whole different can of worms.
link
nightpool 675 days ago
> it is a kestrel requirement to do ssl termination

Couldn't you just pass it x-forwarded-proto like any other web server? or use a different self signed key between nginx and kestrel instead?

link