Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thayne 688 days ago
To explain why it can be removed in the former:

Since it is UB to dereference a null pointer, the compiler can assume that ptr isn't null after it is dereferenced[1]. Therefore, the if condition will always be false.

In fact if ptr is null, unless the foo field has a very large offset, the behavior you would probably expect would be for the dereference to segfault before reaching the if, so it doesn't really matter if it is optimized away.

1 comments

>so it doesn't really matter if it is optimized away.

There are cases in which the optimization can result in behavior other than segfaulting, see https://research.swtch.com/ub#null

Sure. That's why I said "the behavior you would probably expect", but that isn't necessarily what happens.