Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hosh 690 days ago
There are tools that can do that, and are not as complex as Kubernetes

I once interviewed at a place where their notion of "scaling" is to turn up the knob on Heroku. They also pay for it. They did not have anyone on their team who knew what questions to ask. They had grown to the point where they had outgrown their approach, and yet, have never developed the in-house capability.

I mentioned the Cynefine framework elsewhere, and I'll mention it again. Infrastructure and how it supports application, users, stakeholders, is a complex system.

A lot of people treat this as if it were in the complicated, or even clear domain. For certain class of use-cases, you can get away with this. But a company itself is a complex adaptive system, whose needs changes as it matures and scales ... or it doesn't, and it collapses.

The Cynefine framework describes four different domains, and the way you make decisions are different for each of them. You start getting in trouble when you attempt to use the decision-making process for one domain to a different domain. This often happens when the situation has evolved without the decision-makers noticing. It is easier for experts to see how clear domains changes to complicated domains, but it is more difficult to see when complicated domains change to complex domains.

Kubernetes is a sophisticated, adaptive, extensible tool for the complex domain. If it seems overly complex, it is because the domain is complex, and is not necessary if you are working from the complicated or clear domain.

1 comments

No idea why you're being downvoted. Makes sense to me.