Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cchi_co 684 days ago
Piracy undermines the creators' rights still. And I think that a legal framework should do its job
1 comments

Creators were never supposed to have indefinite rights. Copyright has an expiration date to balance fhe rights of the public and author.
In the US the author's rights don't even come into the motivation. They don't exist a priori as free speech would let you share any "IP" you want. The temporary monopoly is ONLY granted to encourage more creation, not as a recognition of author rights.

In the EU it's a bit more complicated but I still don't see authors rights as a primary motivator for copyright specifically.

sure, and we can adjust that without abolishing copyright, nor justifying what is basically theft to go around it. I don't know why every-time this conversation comes up peopel instantly go to "abolish copyright". Is no one else here a creator of some kind?