Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Sanzig 695 days ago
Rad hard parts are basically never sold through distributors. Strict lot traceability is a requirement on space programs (to avoid the issue discussed in the article). The quality departments at the manufacturer and buyer also need to communicate a whole bunch of stuff (requirements, test reports, etc) which defeats the purpose of the insulating layer of a distributor. Also, while these parts are expensive (my rule of thumb is to add 2-3 zeros to the cost of a commercial part to estimate the cost of a rad hard version), they are low volume, so there's not a whole lot in it for a distributor. The contractor working on the electronics almost certainly purchased these parts directly from Infineon, and Infineon would have had records of who purchased parts from which lot.
1 comments

I'll assume everything you say is right :)

The question here is whether Infineon had a contract with NASA or otherwise should have known these were sold to NASA.

Again there is nothing cited in the article that says "yes".

If you've got data that says yes, awesome, what is it?

The fact that they found out about this accidentally at a conference is, all by itself, extremely strong evidence that Infineon didn't notify whoever they should have for the Europa Clipper mission, whether that was NASA itself, an in-house contractor or an external subcontractor.