[darby_nine]

> The vastly overwhelming body of evidence clearly indicates that today humanity is materially and by nearly all concrete measurements of human well-being better off than at any time in all its long history.

I mostly agree, but my point was that materialist analysis has obvious limits. It also naturally favors industrial society as industrial society optimizes for material production (not necessarily material satisfaction, mind you, hence why I mostly agree)

> If you want to make a case for the "natural" life of simple pleasures

If you presume superiority by comparison to our modern "complex" pleasures, sure, you're not going to find much interesting in the past.

> If you want that kind of life today, within the relative safety net of modern medicine and economic support in a wider sense, you're free to pursue it as intensely as you like, and more safely than you ever could have before.

You will still be haunted by what you have seen of other humans and heard from their lips—there's no escaping that.