[filipezf]

As a sibling comment put, the Scott Aaronson post has lots of interesting questions about this. Do the aliens who are watching us being simulated inside matrix think we are actually conscious? What if they freeze the program for 100 years, or run the computation encrypted, or if the 'computer' is just a human inside a room shuffling papers? Is the computer simulation of a water drop wet ?

I found this article [0] very insightful, where they basically propose that consciousness is relative to whom you ask. We inside the simulation may attribute consciousness to each other. The aliens running it may not. What is relevant is the degree of isomorphism between our simulated brain processes and their real ones. So things will advance from all these back-and-forth nebulous arguments only when neuroscience becomes able to explain mechanistically why people claim to be conscious.

[0] A Relativistic Theory of Consciousness. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10....