Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by voldacar 714 days ago
AM sounds painfully awful
5 comments

That "sound" is partially due to the design of the current AM system. It was built to pack more transmitters into the allocated frequency range.

There are no technical impediments to high fidelity audio because of amplitude modulation. In the past the big limitation was the bandwidth of intermediate frequency (IF) amplifiers in the receivers which were typically tuned for maximum gain and not flat audio band response. The transmitters have flat response out to the legal limits. Radio stations have a monitor receiver that has proper IF audio response and the sound of those are very good.

For a while there was an AM Stereo which sounded much better
And there are some stations in the US still broadcasting in AM Stereo AKA C-QUAM, if you have an AM stereo capable receiver that is.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-QUAM

So does DAB. It’s way the hell compressed.

Not that I care too much, as I basically only do on demand media these days.

Agree for music. Hard disagree for voice.

Especially in the car! I can’t make out voices on FM at all. But AM, easy.

You should listen to some DAB+ for comparison. I heard that 56kbps can make wonders. /s
That's he-aac so 56kpbs is not that bad, it gets dicey below 32kbps when you need tricks like parametric stereo. But he-aac's spectral band replication does add metallic taste to everything, i would agree